[00:00:00] As a business owner, you need to understand what your email numbers actually mean. You need to know if your email strategy is working, and you need to know if you should keep investing time in it or if something needs to change.
Hey friend, welcome back to In The EllaMents. I'm Alishia Egenhoff, digital ad strategist, mentor, and the heart behind Social EllaMents Marketing. Around here, we talk about marketing, motherhood, and what it really looks like to build a business while also being a human with limited time, energy, and capacity.
Today, we're talking about something that honestly, I think it confuses a lot of business owners, and that's email stats, and specifically why the numbers you're seeing in your email platform might not match what you think is actually happening. Have you ever looked at your email report and thought, "Wait, something doesn't add up here. Like, my platform says 5,000 people clicked on this link, but my website only showed 500 people arriving from that email"? [00:01:00] Or you're wondering if your open rates are actually good or if you're wasting your time sending emails even at all. This episode is for you.
So here's what happened. I have a client who was looking at their email metrics and was genuinely confused and concerned. They said, "Alishia, my email platform is telling me I got 5,000 clicks on the link I shared, but when I look at my website analytics, the actual place where people landed, I only saw 500 clicks. What is going on? Is my email not working? Did I lose just, like, 4,500 clicks somewhere? Help me understand." But here's the thing, and this kind of, you know, is crazy, but both of those numbers are actually correct. Both are true, but they were measuring very different things, and that's what we're unpacking today.
Because as a business owner, you need to understand what your email [00:02:00] numbers actually mean. You need to know if your email strategy is working, and you need to know if you should keep investing time in it or if something needs to change.
So when your email platform counts a click, it's counting something different than what your website sees, and that's where the disconnect starts. So your email platform counts a click when someone's email client, Gmail, Outlook, Apple Mail, Yahoo, whatever it is, registers that a link was clicked.
Sounds simple, right? But here's where it does get complicated. There are security systems behind almost every email account. These are tools that these companies use to scan links before they let you click on them. They're security features, and they're supposed to protect people from malicious links, which is great, right? We all like to have those safety features.
So your email goes into someone's inbox, they see the link, but before they even click it, the [00:03:00] security scanner has already clicked it. It's automatically checking the link to make sure that it's legitimate and that it's not going to some sketchy website. So from your email platform's perspective, whatever platform you use, that is counted as a click, but it wasn't actually a real human clicking it. It was a bot.
So when my client's email platform said that they had 5,000 clicks, a bunch of those were actually from those security scanners. But when people actually landed on their website, that's when their analytics saw them, and that's the real human traffic. That's the number that really matters to them. But also, that's why the number was so much lower. Both numbers are accurate in terms of clicks, but they're just measuring different things, and there's no way to differentiate that through an email platform. Your email platform is counting every single click that happens, and your website or whatever you're sending them to is only counting the people who actually made it through.
But [00:04:00] clicks aren't the only place where the math just stops adding up. Opens are, too. Apple Mail privacy protection came out a few years ago, and it basically changed how email open rates work. If someone is using Apple Mail and they have a privacy protection turned on, which by the way is on by default, Apple automatically opens every email in your list, whether the person actually reads it or not.
Your email platform counts that as an open, but did the person actually open it? Probably not. Apple's servers did, or whatever software they're using did. And it's not just Apple. Gmail has AI overviews now. Yahoo and Outlook have their own privacy features. All of these are automatically opening emails for security or preview reasons, and all of those count as opens in your reports.
I actually stopped obsessing over open rates because of this. [00:05:00] They used to be this gold standard metric. If you could hit that 30%, you were doing amazing. But now, that number includes a ton of automated opens that don't actually tell you if a real person engaged with your email. Click-through rate actually matters more now. If someone actually clicks your link, that's way more meaningful. That's actually somebody who cared enough to take action, and that's real engagement
And just to add another layer to this, not all email platforms are measuring the same way. So I personally use Flodesk for my business, and I love it, but Flodesk's numbers are going to be different from Email Octopus, which is going to be different from Mailchimp, which is different from Shopify or Brevo or Constant Contact.
They're all handling security, privacy features, and bot detection a little differently, and some platforms are better at filtering out bot clicks, while some count opens more aggressively than others, and some give you clearer insight into what's actually a human engagement versus what's [00:06:00] automated. The important thing is, though, is to know your platform, to understand it.
So read their documentation, reach out to support, understand how their counting opens and clicks, because if you're comparing your Flodesk numbers to your website analytics, you're not comparing the same thing. You're comparing what Flodesk is measuring to what your website is measuring, and they're two different systems.
When you're looking at your email stats, you have to understand the context. Your email platform is showing you email engagement. Your website analytics are showing you conversion and traffic. Both are useful, but they're measuring different parts of the customer journey.
So we've talked about why your numbers might be confusing, but knowing the problem is half of it. You need to know what to do with this information, and the answer is segmentation. Let me give you a real example. I have a list of people who have bought from me or worked with me, and I have a list of people who haven't bought from me yet. [00:07:00] They get completely different emails. Why? Because the metrics are going to be totally different.
People who bought something from you already know you. They trust you. They're way more engaged. They open more emails, and they click more. They're probably going to buy again, or they're more likely to take the next action you're asking them to take, versus people who haven't bought yet, their engagement is lower.
This is like dating. They're still figuring out if you're worth their time and money, and they're in the awareness and consideration phase, not the purchase phase. So if you lump everybody together and just look at your overall email stats, you get this averaged out number that doesn't really tell you anything.
It's looking at a blurry picture. But if you segment and take out those lists separately, you can see what's actually working. You can see, okay, my customers are opening at thirty percent and clicking at eight percent. That's amazing. My prospects are [00:08:00] opening at twelve percent and clicking at two percent.
That's lower, but that makes sense because they're earlier in the journey. When you segment, you stop making decisions based on confused averages, and you start making decisions based on what's actually happening. With the right people.
So you're looking at your email stats, and you're not sure what's actually working. You're wondering if your email is even worth your time, and what do you actually check? Because I just dumped a whole bunch of information on you. So here's my five-point email audit that will actually tell you what is going on.
So first, delivery rate. Are your emails actually getting to people's inboxes? If your delivery is below 95%, you've got a problem. Maybe you have authentication issues, or your list has a bunch of dead email addresses. FloDesk actually handles a lot of this for you, but you should still check and [00:09:00] know what your number is.
Next is open rate, but here's the key. Contextualize it. If you're getting 15 to 20% open rates, that's pretty solid. But remember that some of those are automated opens from Apple and Gmail and other softwares. This number alone does not tell you the whole story.
Third is your click-through rate. This is where the real story is. So if you're getting two to five percent click-through rate, meaning two to five out of every one hundred people who opened your email actually click something, that's actually very healthy, and I know it seems like a low number, but it's actually very healthy. Below one percent, something's off. Maybe your content isn't resonating, or your call to action isn't clear enough. It's worth digging into and maybe trying some testing with.[00:10:00]
And then fourth, your unsubscribe rate. If you're getting more than point five percent of people unsubscribing from a single email, that's a signal that maybe your message wasn't right, or maybe you're sending too often. Some unsubscribes are normal, especially if you're growing your list. But if it's high, listen to that signal. I've also seen a pretty high unsubscribe rate from a dead list, you haven't been sending to that list regularly, and then all of a sudden, you start sending to that list. So, understand that if you just up and start sending emails weekly and you haven't been doing that, that you're gonna see a higher unsubscribe rate.
Fifth is your list health. Is your list growing, or is it shrinking? Are you cleaning out those inactive people regularly? Dead email addresses and unengaged subscribers actually hurt your sender reputation and make your metrics worse, so cleaning your list regularly is important.
[00:11:00] Those five things give you a real picture of what's actually happening instead of obsessing over just one vanity metric. So hopefully that's helpful to you. And then once you know what to check, you need to know what you're actually looking for, so, like, what's good and what's not.
So open rates, I generally say a 10 to 15% open rate is healthy, and if you're consistently above that, you're doing really well. But consider open rates, what we talked about earlier, are an inflated metric. Below 5%, though, something needs to change. Either your subject line might not be working, your list might not be the right fit, or maybe you're sending too often. So maybe try some testing of things to see if you can get that to come up.
Your click-through rate, a 2 to 5% is really, like, a sweet spot. That's, that's good engagement, and those are people who actually cared enough to click. So if you're seeing those numbers, like, you are golden.
Unsubscribe rate, [00:12:00] ideally, we wanna keep it below that .5%. If you're consistently losing half a percent or more of your list with every email, your messaging is probably not landing right, but there's other factors to consider here, like we talked about earlier. So keep that in mind.
And then conversion rate, this depends on what you're asking people to do. If you're selling something, a 1 to 2% of clicks converting to a purchase is actually really solid. If you're asking them to join a free challenge, it might be higher, only because that barrier is lower, but just a 1 to 2% of clicks converting is generally a pretty solid number to be in.
Your list growth rate, you should be adding more people to your list than you're losing. And if your list is shrinking, you need more new subscribers, or you're sending emails that are too aggressive. So there's different ways to grow an email list. My favorite way is to actually just run ads to a freebie of some sort to grow that list, but, we could dive into [00:13:00] that and other ways of growing your funnel and your customer journey.
But here's the real talk. These are just guidelines for you. So you need to understand that your industry matters, your audience type matters, the size of your list matters. I mean, I've had clients with 2,000 engaged subscribers who get better result than people with 50,000 subscribers who just don't care.
So quality beats size every time. Remember that. But the point isn't to hit some magic number. The point is to understand your baseline and know if you're actually improving over time. Are your emails getting better engagement? Are more people taking action? Those are the things that actually matter.
So if you've audited your numbers, you know your benchmarks, now what? If your open rates are low, but your click rates are high, that tells you something. The people who do read your emails do really care, and maybe you need to work on your subject lines to get more opens, but your core audience is [00:14:00] solid.
If your click rates are low, that's telling you your content isn't resonating, or maybe your call to action isn't clear. People take the path of least resistance, so make sure your call to actions are super clear. And this is something easy to fix because it's about relevance and clarity and not just volume.
If your unsubscribe rate is creeping up, do pay attention to that. Your audience is telling you something here, and maybe you're sending too often, or maybe your messaging doesn't match their expectations of what they signed up for. So pay attention to that signal.
And when you understand what your numbers mean, you can make better decisions about your email strategy. You're not just guessing. You're making intentional choices based on data and real numbers.
But here's what's important. Email is still one of the most direct ways to reach your audience. It's not about having the biggest list, and it's not about having an engaged list of [00:15:00] people who actually want to hear from you. It's actually getting into somebody's inbox, which is a personal space, and resonating enough that people want to engage with you and what you're selling.
We've talked about all the confusing metrics and how to interpret them, but I wanna be real with you and really help you understand why you should even care about email in the first place, and it's because email is yours. You own that list. You own that relationship with those people.
Social media, you're at the mercy of the algorithm. Instagram can change how your, reach works tomorrow. TikTok might get banned. It's happened before. Facebook can deprioritize your content. You have zero control. But your email list is different. Those people signed up because they want to hear from you.
You send the message directly to their inbox. There's [00:16:00] no algorithm that gets to decide whether they see it or not. You're not dependent on a platform. And something most people don't think about is that your email list is actually very, very valuable. Like, really valuable. If you ever need to change platforms, if you hit a business crisis, if you need to pivot your business, you have a direct line of communication to your audience.
You don't need Meta or Google or TikTok to do that. That's why you should care about email. Not because the metrics are perfect or easy to understand, but because it's the one channel that you actually have control over. And when you understand what your metrics actually mean, when you understand and you know what's real engagement and what's just bots, when you know how your platform is counting those things, when you're being intentional about your segmentation and your strategy, you can build an email business that actually works for you.[00:17:00]
So here's my challenge for you after this episode. Go into your email platform right now. Pull up your last email send. Look at the metrics. Do you understand what you're looking at? Do you know your baseline open rate, your click-through rate? Do you know which segment of your audience is most engaged? If not, do that audit I mentioned earlier.
Check your delivery, opens, clicks, unsubscribes, and list health, and get a real understanding of what's happening. And then go ask yourself, "Is this working for my business? Are people engaging? Are they taking the action I want? If not, what needs to change?" When you understand your email stats and you know what they actually mean, you can build a strategy around that, that works, and you're gonna stop wasting time on things that aren't working, and you double down on what is.
If you want to stay connected, I'd love to have you on my email list. I send two to four emails a month with honest thoughts on marketing, [00:18:00] motherhood, and building a business that fits your real life. You can join through the link in the show notes. And if this episode helped you finally understand what your email metrics mean, I want to hear about it.
Shoot me a message, or better yet, share this with another business owner who's been confused by their email stats. Thanks for spending time with me In the EllaMents. Until next time, keep building with intention and give yourself grace as you grow.